There are three recent questions that are asking about how things would be different on a fictional "alternate earth" with different parameters:
It's previously been established that geoscience questions related to other (real) planets are on topic, but that's a little different to "if earth were different in parameters A and B, how would things X and Y be different".
We've previously discussed "movie science" questions, although I'm not sure whether consensus was reached, but these questions are different - they're reasonable geoscience questions (albeit mostly too broad at the moment) that happen to relate to a fictitious, hypothetical scenario. They would certainly be on topic at Worldbuilding, but that doesn't mean that they don't also belong here.
Should these questions be on-topic at Earth Science? If so, how should they be signposted to make it clear that they do not refer to reality? (a tag? A prefix to the title?)